Why Does Sending ERC20 Tokens Require Two Transactions? Blockchain Basics Explained

Understanding ERC20 Token Transfers

Blockchain technology has revolutionized digital transactions, and ERC20 tokens play a pivotal role in this ecosystem. Unlike sending Ether (ETH), transferring ERC20 tokens involves a two-step process that often puzzles newcomers. Let’s demystify this mechanism in simple terms.

The Intuitive Nature of Ether Transfers

Sending ETH is straightforward:
– You initiate a transaction from your wallet
– The recipient’s balance increases instantly
– No intermediate steps are required

This simplicity stems from ETH being Ethereum’s native currency, directly managed by the blockchain protocol.

👉 Discover how blockchain transactions work

The Complexity Behind ERC20 Tokens

ERC20 tokens operate differently because they’re:
1. Smart contract-based: Each token is governed by its own contract
2. Secondary assets: They exist as entries in contract storage, not native blockchain assets
3. Permission-dependent: Contracts require explicit approval to move tokens

Key Components:

  • EOA (Externally Owned Account): User-controlled wallets
  • Contract Accounts: Programmable smart contracts
  • Token Ledger: Storage within each ERC20 contract

The Two-Transaction Process Explained

Transaction 1: Approval (Approve)

Before any token transfer can occur:

  1. Authorization: You grant permission to a specific contract
  2. Limit Setting: Define how many tokens can be accessed
  3. Security: This prevents unauthorized access to your funds

solidity
// Example approve function call
approve(spenderAddress, amount);

Transaction 2: Transfer Execution

After approval is confirmed:

  1. Action Initiation: You request the actual transfer
  2. Contract Interaction: The approved contract moves your tokens
  3. Completion: Recipient receives the tokens

Real-World Example: Uniswap Token Swap

Consider swapping cDAI to ETH on Uniswap:

  1. Approval Phase:
  2. Authorize Uniswap to access your cDAI
  3. Transaction sent to Compound’s cDAI contract

  4. Swap Execution:

  5. Uniswap contract pulls your cDAI
  6. Sends equivalent ETH to your wallet
  7. All occurs in a single atomic operation

👉 Learn about decentralized exchanges

Why Maximum Approvals Are Common

Most dApps request unlimited approvals because:
User convenience: Avoid repeated approvals
Gas efficiency: Saves transaction costs
Streamlined UX: Better user experience

However, security-conscious users should:
– Set specific limits when possible
– Revoke unused approvals regularly
– Only interact with audited contracts

Security Considerations

Risk Factor Mitigation Strategy
Malicious contracts Verify contract addresses
Approval exploits Use token allowance checkers
Phishing scams Double-check transaction details

FAQ Section

Q: Can I send ERC20 tokens in one transaction?

A: No, the two-step process is fundamental to how ERC20 tokens operate on Ethereum.

Q: Why don’t native coins like ETH need approval?

A: ETH is part of Ethereum’s base layer, while ERC20 tokens are implemented as smart contracts.

Q: Is the approval transaction always necessary?

A: Yes, unless you’ve previously approved that specific spender for that token.

Q: How can I check my existing approvals?

A: Use tools like Etherscan’s Token Approvals checker to review and revoke permissions.

Q: What happens if I approve a malicious contract?

A: The contract could potentially drain all tokens of that type from your wallet.

Q: Can I change an existing approval amount?

A: Yes, you can update the approval by sending a new approve transaction.

Best Practices for ERC20 Token Management

  1. Verify contracts before approving
  2. Use dedicated wallets for DeFi interactions
  3. Monitor approvals regularly
  4. Consider gas costs when setting approval amounts
  5. Stay informed about new security developments

Understanding this two-transaction mechanism helps users navigate DeFi more safely and confidently. While it may seem complex initially, this design pattern enables the rich ecosystem of interoperable tokens that make Ethereum so powerful.

👉 Explore secure token management