If you’ve researched Bitcoin even briefly, you’ve likely encountered the tired critique: “Bitcoin has no intrinsic value.” This claim resurfaced recently when geopolitical analyst Peter Zeihan repeated it on Joe Rogan’s podcast, misleading millions. But is this argument valid? Let’s dismantle it systematically.
The Flawed Concept of “Intrinsic Value”
Value Is Subjective, Not Intrinsic
The term “intrinsic value” is a misnomer. Value is inherently subjective—it reflects individual or collective esteem for an asset. You can’t isolate “value” as a physical property, whether in gold, water, or Bitcoin.
- Example: Water is vital for survival, yet its perceived value fluctuates (e.g., bottled water vs. tap water).
- Market Dynamics: Price emerges from supply-demand interactions, not mythical “intrinsic” metrics.
Use Cases Define Value
Assets derive worth from their utility. Consider eggs:
– Primary Use Case: Nutrition (protein/fat content).
– Secondary Value: Culinary versatility.
Similarly, Bitcoin’s value stems from its properties as money, not arbitrary declarations.
Bitcoin’s Use Case: Superior Money
Money must fulfill three core functions (Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis):
1. Store of value
2. Medium of exchange
3. Unit of account
Bitcoin’s code enforces six critical properties that optimize it for these roles:
| Property | Bitcoin’s Advantage |
|---|---|
| Divisibility | Splits into 100 million satoshis (fractions of a penny). |
| Durability | Digital, immune to decay. |
| Fungibility | Each unit is identical and interchangeable. |
| Portability | Globally transmissible in minutes via the Lightning Network. |
| Scarcity | Fixed supply of 21 million coins. |
| Acceptability | Accessible to anyone with internet; nodes can be run independently. |
👉 Why Bitcoin’s scarcity makes it the ultimate hedge against inflation
Why Competing Assets Fall Short
- Fiat Currency: Lacks scarcity (unlimited printing erodes value).
- Gold: Durable but illiquid (hard to divide/transport).
- Real Estate: Scarce but immovable.
Bitcoin uniquely combines scarcity, portability, and decentralization, making it the first globally neutral money.
Addressing Volatility Concerns
Critics cite Bitcoin’s price swings as a weakness, but volatility stems from:
1. Adoption Cycles: Early-stage asset discovery.
2. Market Liquidity: Still maturing compared to gold/fiat.
3. Macro Shocks: Leverage liquidations amplify moves.
Long-term, volatility decreases as adoption grows—a pattern seen in all emerging stores of value.
👉 How to dollar-cost average into Bitcoin wisely
FAQ: Bitcoin’s Value Explained
Q1: If value is subjective, why does Bitcoin have a market price?
A1: Price reflects collective demand for its properties (scarcity, censorship resistance, etc.). Markets aggregate subjective valuations.
Q2: How can Bitcoin be “digital gold” if it’s intangible?
A2: Gold’s value isn’t in its physicality but its scarcity and acceptance. Bitcoin improves on gold by being verifiable digitally.
Q3: Could governments ban Bitcoin?
A3: Technically improbable (decentralized network). Historically, bans increase demand (see Nigeria, China).
Q4: What if a better cryptocurrency replaces Bitcoin?
A4: Network effects matter. Bitcoin’s security and brand dominance make displacement unlikely (e.g., no “better email” replaced SMTP).
Conclusion: Bitcoin’s Value Proposition
Bitcoin’s “intrinsic value” lies in its unmatched functionality as money. Its code ensures:
– Predictable scarcity (21M cap).
– Borderless transactions.
– Resistance to confiscation.
The market will continue pricing these attributes—likely higher over time.
“Money is the most salable good,” noted economist Carl Menger. Bitcoin is simply the best salable good humanity has invented.
Want to explore Bitcoin further? 👉 Start your Bitcoin journey here
“`